CastleRock application sparks ALR debate at council

Invermere council voted to support non-farm Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR) use by CastleRock Estates Ltd. Partnership.

Invermere council voted to support non-farm Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR) use by CastleRock Estates Ltd. Partnership at its most recent council meeting.

The company applied to use a 1.7-acre portion of ALR land as a parking lot, so that CastleRock residents can have somewhere to store trailers and boats. The CastleRock community association does not allow people to park trailers and boats in front of their homes.

District staff and council members have been up to tour the site as part of the previous Committee of the Whole meeting several weeks prior, where they learned that work on the parking lot and a road to it had already begun.

“I don’t support the land being used that way,” said councillor Spring Hawes, during discussion of the application at the June 24th council meeting.

A report on the matter prepared for council by district staff had recommended not supporting the application, pointing out the developers’ proposed use of the land was inconsistent with both Invermere’s official community plan and the Imagine Invermere integrated community sustainability plan. The report also noted that the hayfields on the ALR land in the application have not been used as hayfields for some time and that, as development in Castle Rock has progressed, parts of the fields have been used as dumping areas for excavated fill and debris.

“All of our policy does not support CastleRock using this land to make a parking lot,” said councillor Paul Denchuk, adding he has heard one rancher make reference to the specific piece of land, saying you can’t graze cows there, but has also heard another rancher say that, in fact, you could graze cows there.

“To me, the reasons given on why it shouldn’t be in the ALR and should be a parking lot were fabricated,” said Mr. Denchuk. “We don’t have a lot of ALR land in our boundaries. It is important.”

Several councillors also took issue with the company starting work on the land well before the application was made.

Councillor Greg Anderson said he was troubled that CastleRock skipped due process and went ahead with work before making its application. By the same token, the ALR land in question is only 1.7 acres and is well hidden from view, he said.

“The cost to remove the fill and return the site to its original state is unrealistic. And the CastleRock community does have a need for that parking space,” said Mr. Anderson. “The 1.7 acres is just the tip of a larger section of ALR land, (the parking lot) doesn’t break up that parcel into small pieces.”

Ms. Hawes said it was a matter of principle ― that agricultural land should be protected and that the developer should not have begun work before getting approval.

“I’m absolutely opposed to somebody making free with the policies and regulations we have in place. There are other opportunities and places for CastleRock to provide that parking space,” she said.

“I don’t think it’s as big a deal as you’re making it out to be,” said councillor Justin Atterbury to Ms. Hawes and Mr. Denchuk, adding the developer

has indicated the possibility of using another part of CastleRock land for agricultural purposes in exchange for being allowed to build the parking lot on the specific spot where the work has started.

“I think if the developer is willing to trade, there’s no net loss of land and the whole thing is a net benefit for CastleRock residents,,” said Mr. Atterbury.

Ms. Hawes said that, from her understanding, only a temporary exchange had been offered, and that it would be different if the developer were to offer a permanent change.

“Where do you draw the line? For sure the developer is going to come back and ask for more (ALR non-farm uses) in the future,” said Mr. Denchuk. “The only reason they need this parking lot is that (CastleRock residents) are not allowed to park their boats and trailers in front of their homes. That to me is crazy.”

Mr. Denchuk later told The Valley Echo that, based on council’s tour of the area several weeks ago, it seemed work on the parking lot may have begun quite some time before the application was made. He also added that he suspects the developer may have been well aware of the need to submit an application before work began, but simply didn’t do it.

“There are countless acreages within the ALR in the valley that see zero agricultural activity,” said Invermere mayor Gerry Taft. “When it comes to protecting agriculture in this area, I don’t think this is the hill to die on. I don’t think (the 1.7 acres) is prime agricultural land and I don’t think it will revert to being productively used for agriculture if we vote against the application. If we do vote for it, a few people will park recreational vehicles (RVs) and boats on a spot where nobody else will notice. There’s no reason we shouldn’t try to build a good relationship with the developer.”

“The only relationship we’re supporting with this is a do-first, then-ask relationship. I can’t support that,” replied Mr. Denchuk.

“There are sometimes more things to consider than the idea that the ALR is sacred and can’t be touched. Sometimes there’s too much focus on the ALR,” countered Mr. Taft.

“Sometimes there’s too much focus on parking lots,” shot back Mr. Denchuk.

Council voted three-to-two to support the CastleRock Estates Ltd. Partnership application, with Mr. Taft, Mr. Anderson and Mr. Atterbury voting to support it, and Ms. Hawes and Mr. Denchuk voting not to support it.


Just Posted

The end of an Echo
The end of an Echo

Invermere Valley Echo shuts down operations in Columbia Valley

Creating a new narrative for Canal Flats

Economic development consultant hired, lists vision for next 90 days

Princeton wildfire phots courtesy of Debbie Lyon.
UPDATE: Crews battle as wildfires rage in B.C. Interior

Crews brace for another day on B.C. firelines as no let up is likely

VIDEO: B.C. wildfires by the numbers
VIDEO: B.C. wildfires by the numbers

Wildfires continue to engulf regions of B.C.’s forests and communities.

Aerial view south of Williams Lake Friday afternoon shows dry lightning storm passing over, leaving fire starts behind. Lightning sparked more than 100 new fires Friday. (Black Press)
VIDEO: More than 180 wildfires burning across B.C.

Firefighters from other provinces called in to assist

DTSS Grad March 2017
DTSS Grad March 2017

DTSS Grad March 2017

59 cats seized in Chase
59 cats seized in Chase

59 neglected and injured cats were seized from a property in Chase

(Flickr/Andreas Eldh)
Soundgarden singer Chris Cornell dead at age 52

The singer/songwriter passed away early Thursday morning in Detroit

Paying tribute to a primeval passage
Paying tribute to a primeval passage

Uninterrupted celebrates the Adams River sockeye run in an extraordinary way.

UPDATE: Pemberton Music Festival cancelled, no automatic refunds
UPDATE: Pemberton Music Festival cancelled, no automatic refunds

In the past, the music festival located in Pemberton drew large crowds last year of 180,000 fans

Photo by:
Medical wait times cost B.C. patients $2,300 each

New Fraser Institute report places B.C. at second worst in costs associated with long wait times

UPDATE: 22 killed at Ariana Grande concert
UPDATE: 22 killed at Ariana Grande concert

Witnesses reported hearing two loud bangs coming from near the arena’s bars at about 10:35 p.m.

A university study finds that about nine per cent of Canada’s Grade 11 and 12 students – roughly 66,000 teens – have driven within an hour of drinking and 9.4 per cent drove after using marijuana.                                 Photo: Now-
Leader file
One in three Canadian high school students have rode with drinking drivers, study reveals

Nearly one in five rode with a driver who’d been smoking pot

Top court to hear federal government’s appeal on residential school records
Top court to hear federal government’s appeal on residential school records

A lower court judge ruled to destroy the stories after 15 years unless consent is given to preserve

Most Read